Water Scarcity: The Reality or a Metaphor?

In the last post, I highlight the importance of holding a more careful view of some overall thinking and statistics on African issues. In this post, I will continue this argument and discuss the complexity of water issues in Africa, by reflecting the concept of water scarcity, which is often misused when talking about water issues in Africa.

Water scarcity is a concept that is often used (and misused) when talking about African water issues. Organizations aiming to solve water-related problems often use statements like "around 5 billion people could be living in areas of water scarcity by 2050" to catch readers' attention. However, people seldom really understand this concept nor realize how it might oversimplify water issues when using it. 

Then what is water scarcity? 

A series of indicators are developed to measure water scarcity in the last few decades. Falkenmark (1989) devised one of the first metrics, the water stress index (WSI), and started formal quantification of water scarcity. WSI defines a threshold for water stress, which is 1000 m3 per capita per year. Such crude quantification presumes a universal water demand and this could be fixed by another metric named withdrawal-to-availability ratio (WTA), which defines water scarcity by the ratio of water demand from different sectors to annual renewable freshwater (Raskin et al., 1996).

These two metrics both are more inclined to "physical" water scarcity and have plentiful limitations as reflected by Damkjaer & Taylor (2017). For instance, using mean annual river runoff (MARR) to estimate available freshwater resources would ignore other components like groundwater storage in the hydraulic cycle, which is also an important water source for agriculture and domestic consumption in Africa (MacDonald et al., 2012). Calculation on a yearly basis implicitly neglects the seasonal variability of river discharge, which is especially influential to water availability in semi-arid and arid regions. The potential of storage to improve water accessibility is also excluded. A number of other metrics are designed to address these limitations and include social, economic and environmental factors in water scarcity. However, possibly due to their simple and relatively less-cost calculation mechanism, WSI and WTA are still widely used in large scale statistics (see for example Figure 1). 


Figure 1: Water scarcity map in 2018 UN World Water Development Report which applies WTA. Statistics in this report was the source of the "5 billion people will live with water scarcity" statement mentioned above.

Beyond water scarcity...

Unlike some static resources like land, water is a very complex resource. The water cycle contains a series of dynamic and interactive components like rainfall, evaporation, soil moisture and groundwater storage. Water resource has "enormous temporal and spatial variations as well as variations in quality that completely govern its value to people and ecosystems" (Rijsberman,2005).

As discussed above, the concept of water scarcity implied in some large-scale metric statistics oversimplifies water issues. Various hydraulic conditions and social-economic backgrounds are hidden in single indicator maps like Figure 1. It is important to jump out of the concept of water scarcity and realize people who live in "no water scarcity" regions can also lack safe drinking water due to poor or unaffordable water services. Similarly, some regions defined as water-scared might indeed don't face severe water issues if abundant groundwater storage could supplement water supply. 

It's also crucial to recognise Africa's existing geographical heterogeneity in terms of water resources. Africa has a diverse range of climatic systems, ranging from humid equatorial to seasonally dry tropical to sub-tropical Mediterranean climates (Goulden et al., 2010). Mean annual precipitation in African river basins could range from less than 500mm to more than 1,500mm within the continent (Figure 2). The impact of climate change would also impose various influences in different regions of the continent (I will explore this more in the next post). The problem with Africa's water resources is significantly more intricate than just declaring that a particular number of people are living in water-scarce regions.

Figure 2: Rainfall variability in African river basins. Source: Wit & Stankiewicz, 2006

In short, this post continues to against the overgeneralization of African water issues, as the reality of water resources in Africa is far more complicated than the concept of water scarcity. Especially when it comes to water resource management, it is important for us to move away from these large-scale statistics of water conditions to find more context-specific solutions. 

评论

  1. Clement2021年11月16日 18:45

    Your idea of water scarcity and arguments for and against conventional metrics for measuring water scarcity is well laid out. It was also useful that you focused on the misconception and complexity of water scarcity. You presented a good engagement with the literature but your references need to be embeded.

    回复删除
    回复
    1. Leshi Li2021年11月29日 01:25

      I am glad that you like this post and thank you for reminding me to improve the embedding references!

      删除

发表评论

此博客中的热门博文

Food and Water in Africa: Start with a More Careful View

图片
Hi and welcome to my blog! This blog will include a series of posts to discuss some key issues and potential solutions relating to the topic of Food and Water in the African context. In this first post, I would like to start with some reflections about how should we view water and food issues in this continent. Almost undeniably, water and food are two essential preconditions of life, which are also strongly interlinked. Only with sufficient quantity and acceptable quality of water, food security could be achieved to support other economic and social development within a country  (Vilakazi et al., 2019) . In other words, water is incontestably embedded in food safety.  In terms of water and food in Africa, you probably have seen or known the following statements before:      Over 600 million Africans are experiencing water shortages.       Nearly one-fifth of the African population is suffering from hunger  (FAO, 2021) .      Agriculture consumes over 83% of overall freshwater withdraw
阅读全文

GMOs: Changing the Crop Africans Grow

图片
In the previous two posts, I addressed two solutions to Africa's water and food scarcity challenges: correcting unequal time distribution of water resources through storage systems and easing asymmetrical geographical distribution via virtual water trade . Both of these ideas stem from the desire to make better use of current water supplies – but what if we could address the problem by changing the crops we grow? As an outcome of modern biotechnological development, Genetically Modified Organisms (GMOs) have always been burdened with both expectations and opprobrium. GMOs, according to the FAO , are species 'in which one or more genes have been introduced into its genetic material from another organism using recombinant DNA technology. This approach allows for the development of crop traits (such as disease resistance, lower water and nutrient input requirements, higher yield and nutrition and so on) that may adapt to a broader range of growing environments, hence addressing f
阅读全文

Water Storage: More Than Dam it

图片
We may conclude from the broad data discussions in previous posts that managing water and food security in Africa is complex and requires localised oversight. In this and the following post, I'll move to several potential solutions towards agriculture-related water shortages, as well as their impact and limits, using particular case studies. In most African countries, the economy and livelihood systems are strongly reliant on rainfall ( Boelee et al., 2013 ), which is inherently unevenly distributed in both time and space. Approximately 200 million people in sub-Saharan Africa are food insecure, owing to a reliance on unreliable rain-fed agriculture ( Ward et al. 2007 ). According to existing studies (e.g., Thornton et al., 2006 ), current climatic variability in Africa will be worsened by future climate change, which implies water resource managers on the continent will have to deal with increasing water resource uncertainty.  Physical water scarcity is not the most significant li
阅读全文